Federalism and devolution?

A while ago I wrote this post a while ago, when i first received David Melding’s book.  In it he argues that for the union to survive, the UK should look to a federal future.  Mr Melding’s view is a departure from the traditional Conservative view on constitutional matters.   His argument is well thought out, and is likely to find sympathetic ears from both Labour supporters and Plaid supporters.  I’m not as sure how much support he is finding within his own party to this idea.

David Melding has recently written a blog post for the Institute of Welsh Affairs, where he argued that the UK has been one of the most successful states, however many would disagree.  Sure there has been no revolution nor dissolution, however we do have devolution, an ad hoc arrangement that has no real clear direction.

This unplanned (if you could call it that) constitutional arrangement can’t be anything other than ad hoc, after all the entire British constitution is ad hoc, and is designed to suit the needs of which ever party occupies No. 10.  What David Melding argues is that the UK needs a written constitution that outlines the roles of the UK government and the home nations’ governments.  He also suggests that Lords reform should be used to give each home country equality within the a ‘Federal Britain’ through over-representation of Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland.

I for one support a written constitution, and an equal representation to each home country within the Lords; an arrangement that has worked well for each state in the USA.  Of course parliament’s lower chamber would be proportional to the population.

In his posting, David Melding doesn’t go into any detail about the jurisdiction of the UK parliament and the respected devolved bodies.  A federal argument is something I hope develops within the ‘unionist’ parties, only then will Wales have a clear path for devolution.

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “Federalism and devolution?”

  1. Cytuno! Angen mwy o drafodaeth ar yr opsiwn ffederal. Yn gweithio’n dda mewn sawl gwlad.

    1. Byddwn i yn meddwl byddai trafodaeth am ddatganoli yn fwy byddiol os buasai’r pleidiau unoliaethol yn derbyn symudiad tuag at ffederasiwn.

  2. I too like the idea of a Federation. I would like the Irish Republic to be included in that Federation, so that it becomes a Federation of the British Isles. The Queen’s recent vissit to Ireland gives an impression that the Irish people would have no difficulty with the monarch as Head of State for such a Federation.

    1. Personally I would prefer an elected head of state, with a clear written constitution, with as much autonomy as possible to each nation. However, would the Republic’s population accept such a move?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s